Oct 29 – 31, 2026
Essaouira, Morocco
Africa/Casablanca timezone

Social acceptability, territorial justice and Younger generations in the energy transition: the case of the East Naples biogas plant

Oct 29, 2026, 3:15 PM
15m
MOGADOR (Municipal Library of Essaouira)

MOGADOR

Municipal Library of Essaouira

Speaker

Antonella BERRITTO (Università degli studi di Napoli Federico II)

Description

The energy transition cannot be interpreted solely as a technological replacement or an adjustment of infrastructure to meet decarbonisation targets. It constitutes a social, political and territorial process that redefines relationships of trust, the distribution of costs and benefits, forms of participation and visions of the future. From this perspective, ‘green’ infrastructure is not automatically perceived as a public good, particularly when it is introduced into areas characterised by socio-environmental vulnerabilities, a history of urban decay and institutional mistrust.
This paper analyses the case of the planned biogas plant in East Naples, in the Ponticelli neighbourhood, as part of the activities of Spoke 7 of the NEST project – Network for Energy Sustainable Transition. The plant, intended for the treatment of the organic fraction of municipal waste and the production of biogas, biomethane and digestate, has not yet been built, but has already become a subject of public controversy. Its location in a peripheral area characterised by industrialisation, deindustrialisation, the presence of facilities with a high environmental impact, contaminated sites and social fragility allows us to observe how the energy transition is perceived, discussed and contested in vulnerable areas.
The research question concerns the conditions through which the legitimacy – or delegitimisation – of an energy transition infrastructure is constructed in an urban context historically exposed to cumulative environmental burdens. The theoretical framework integrates the literature on the social acceptability of energy innovations with approaches to energy and environmental justice. Acceptability is understood not merely as a measure of consensus, but as a situated and conflictual process in which institutional trust, risk perception, territorial recognition and the assessment of benefit distribution are intertwined.
The research adopts a mixed-methods approach. Institutional documents, administrative records, project sources, press articles, social media groups and online communities were analysed in order to reconstruct the project timeline, the stakeholder ecosystem and the main lines of conflict. This phase was complemented by a socio-demographic profiling of the neighbourhood, the mapping of service- s and infrastructure, 15 semi-structured interviews with local stakeholders, and a questionnaire administered in secondary schools within the Ponticelli area. The school survey made it possible to include the younger generations not merely as recipients of educational policies, but as key actors in understanding the social dimension of the transition.
The results reveal a clear divide between the technical and institutional rationale of the project and the social perception of the area. On the one hand, institutional and technical-administrative stakeholders view the biogas plant as infrastructure necessary for closing the waste cycle, producing renewable energy and meeting circular economy objectives. On the other hand, a significant proportion of civic stakeholders view it as a further environmental burden on an area already marked by ecological inequalities and a long history of unfulfilled institutional promises. The interviews reveal four main findings: fragmented and inadequate institutional communication; a perception of risk centred on odours, traffic, pollution and safety; widespread mistrust in the institutions’ ability to manage and monitor the plant; and participation limited to a small core group of civic activists, without any real involvement of the wider community.
The survey of young people reinforces and clarifies these findings. In schools, there is significant interest in environmental issues and familiarity with everyday sustainability practices, such as energy saving, recycling and waste reduction. However, knowledge of the biogas plant and the project planned for Ponticelli is very limited. This finding confirms that the main critical issue is not a lack of environmental awareness, but a deficit in public information and local education regarding the transition. Young people express a nuanced position: they recognise the potential benefits of the plant, including improved management of organic waste, a reduction in litter on the streets, the production of renewable energy and opportunities for the neighbourhood, but at the same time they voice concerns regarding environmental, health and operational impacts.
The research therefore demonstrates that the social acceptability of green infrastructure is not built after the technical decision has been made, but throughout the entire process of planning, communication and engagement. The case of East Naples highlights that schools can become a social infrastructure for the transition: a space for mediating between expert knowledge and the local community, a place for building trust and a laboratory for climate citizenship. From this perspective, the younger generations represent a decisive lever for transforming the energy transition from a top-down process into a path that is locally recognised, socially debated and democratically governed. In conclusion, it is therefore clear that there is a need to integrate structured participation, transparent communication, environmental education and civic monitoring into green infrastructure planning processes. Only through such measures can the energy transition avoid reproducing new territorial inequalities and, on the contrary, become an opportunity for climate justice, inclusion and community resilience.

Keywords
Energy transition; younger generations; social acceptability; territorial justice; participatory governance.

Selected subject area
9. Territorial resilience and integrated solutions

Author

Antonella BERRITTO (Università degli studi di Napoli Federico II)

Co-authors

Prof. Fabio CORBISIERO (Università degli studi di Napoli Federico II) Dr Carmine URCIUOLI (Università degli studi di Napoli Federico II)

Presentation materials

There are no materials yet.